E-Business: Domain Names - Bad Faith


Ian McMillan registered the internet domain name TrivialPursuits.net and won the right to continue using it, after a challenge from Horn Abbot, the makers of the board game, failed to stop him using the domain name. The makers of the Trivial Pursuits board game failed to obtain the TrivialPursuits.net domain name from the person who said he registered the name to lament life's loss of individual creativity.

This decision has gone against the long established principle that once a brand is "well known", the Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP)1 part of the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO), would be able to effect the transfer of the name. However, in this case, the panel was unclear about the intentions of the respondent, and his motive for registering the domain name. The panel did not believe that there was enough evidence to support an application for bad faith activity on behalf of the respondent.

Respondent Ian McMillan informed the WIPO panellist that he bought the name with with the intention of creating a website dealing with "the 21st Century's unique trivial pursuits, specifically the fact that most aspects of life now involve a commodity as opposed to individual creativity, from sex to salvation via surgery and sweeteners". Currently, the site is only one page long, and refers to the WIPO case as "a fine example of a quite unnecessary and utterly trivial pursuit," adding that more content will be added, "but at the convenience of my lazy nature."

There was little evidence of bad faith found by the panel, although McMillan does not appear to have intention of using the website.

Comment: Usually in cybersquatting cases where there "is no use of a sign in the course of trade" plus difficulty in establishing trade mark infringement or passing off, the UDRP approach is the recommended recourse as it is far cheaper and sometimes quicker.

If you require further information contact us.

Email: enquiries@rtcoopers.com

© RT COOPERS, 2005. This Briefing Note does not provide a comprehensive or complete statement of the law relating to the issues discussed nor does it constitute legal advice. It is intended only to highlight general issues. Specialist legal advice should always be sought in relation to particular circumstances.

Rosanna Cooper is a partner in RT Coopers Solicitors. The firm is a full service commercial law firm covering areas such as E-Business, Education Law, Commercial Litigation, Data Protection, Intellectual Property, Corporate Finance and Commercial Contracts.

Contact us at enquiries@rtcoopers.com. visit our website at http://www.rtcoopers.com







Related News



China limits use of Olympians' names online - Washington Post

Washington Post

China limits use of Olympians' names online
Washington Post, United States -17 hours ago
Domain names based on the names of at least 10 gold medalists, including weightlifter Chen Xiexia and gymnast Yang Wei, were registered before the games, ...
China's Internet chiefs ban names of the GamesXinhua
Ban on golden domain namesChina Daily
China curtails Olympic domainsWeb User
AHN
all 169 news articles

Stay with conventional extensions for Web sites - Palestine Herald Press

Stay with conventional extensions for Web sites
Palestine Herald Press, TX -8 hours ago
If you and your ISP do not have this software installed, the New.net domain name will not work for you.This means that the New.net name will only be ...

Private domain - Inquirer.net

Private domain
Inquirer.net, Philippines -3 hours ago
AFP PHOTO / Greg WOOD China's gold medallists at the Beijing Games will have the exclusive rights to register their own names as internet domain names, ...

Remember123.co.uk Raises Website Recall - Press Dispensary (press release)

Remember123.co.uk Raises Website Recall
Press Dispensary (press release), UK -1 hour ago
Combining online promotion with an affordable web forwarding service that can help businesses improve their online marketing by aiding domain name...

It's All About .ME Now - the new hot domain names - Eworldwire (press release)

It's All About .ME Now - the new hot domain names
Eworldwire (press release), NJ -53 minutes ago
21, 2008 --- When .me domain names became available in June, many people attempted to register while others missed out because they were unaware of the DOT ...

Inttl Advocare - Indlaw.com

Inttl Advocare
Indlaw.com, India -5 hours ago
... Anton Pillar orders, criminal prosecution, computer software, overlap between IP rights and public domain, damages, domain names, cyber laws etc. ...


Name.com Selects NameMedia’s AfternicDLS Domain Sales Platform as ... - Domain Informer (press release)

Name.com Selects NameMedia’s AfternicDLS Domain Sales Platform as ...
Domain Informer (press release), IL -3 hours ago
Under the terms of the agreement, NameMedia’s AfternicDLS global domain sales platform will be the exclusive provider of aftermarket domain names for ...

China’s Sports Bureaucrats Get The Web - MarketWatch

China’s Sports Bureaucrats Get The Web
MarketWatch -14 hours ago
This is in contrast to 2004, when many of the domain names for China’s gold medalists were taken by domain squatters. The sports bureaucracy understands ...

GeoDomainList.com, the Daily Newsletter for Geo Domains, Adds Page ... - PR Web (press release)

GeoDomainList.com, the Daily Newsletter for Geo Domains, Adds Page ...
PR Web (press release), WA -7 hours ago
The domains offered vary daily between Gold, Silver and Bronze level names ranging in price from $20-$50000. DNFolio.com is an aftermarket domain name...

In-house Trademark Attorney Appointed At Domain Registrar Sublime IP - Newswire Today (press release)

In-house Trademark Attorney Appointed At Domain Registrar Sublime IP
Newswire Today (press release), UK -8 hours ago
Fixed pricing in local currencies is available to domain name resellers, trademark attorneys and hosting companies. Trademark registration can be ...